Scurvy is a nutritional disease caused by ascorbic acid (vitamin C) deficiency. Althought currently it is a rare disease, we should considerer it in the differential diagnosis of purpura and arthritis in patients with restrictive diets.
We present the case of a 49-year-old man with a history of a nutritional disorder presented to our hospital with generalized purpura and hemarthros. Following the anamnesis and laboratory findings, rheumatological, infectious and hematological etiologies were excluded. Finally, the diagnosis of scurvy was made upon demostration poor levels of vitamin C and a spectacular response to nutritional supplements. We compare this case with 19 similar cases reported in the medical literature.
El escorbuto es una enfermedad nutricional causada por el déficit de ácido ascórbico (vitamina C). Aunque actualmente es una enfermedad rara, debe tenerse en cuenta en el diagnóstico diferencial ante púrpura y artritis en pacientes con dietas restrictivas.
Presentamos el caso de un varón de 49 años con antecedentes de trastorno de la conducta alimentaria que presenta púrpura generalizada y hemartros. Tras la anamnesis y los hallazgos analíticos, se excluyeron enfermedades de etiología reumatológica, infecciosa y hematológica. Finalmente, se confirmó el diagnóstico de escorbuto tras objetivar niveles deficientes de vitamina C y una espectacular respuesta a los suplementos nutricionales. Comparamos nuestro caso con otros 19 similares, reportados en la literatura médica.
Scurvy is a nutritional disease caused by vitamin C deficiency that was epidemic on sailing voyages from the 15th to the 18th centuries and is now rare in developed countries.1
Vitamin C is a water-soluble vitamin that acts as a reducing agent and is necessary for collagen synthesis. Humans rely on diet and foods high in vitamin C include tomatoes, potatoes, and citrus fruits. The recommended dose is 90 mg/day for men and 75 mg/day for women.2 When vitamin C levels fall to less than 0.15 mg/dL, the typical symptoms of scurvy can develop, characterised by asthenia, joint pain, and vascular fragility, which can lead to petechiae, bleeding gums, haematomas, or hemarthrosis.3,4
Case reportA 49-year-old male with a history of an eating disorder during adolescence was referred to rheumatology for purpura in his lower extremities and bilateral knee arthritis of one month’s duration. During the anamnesis, the patient reported asthenia and episodes of epistaxis. In recent years, his diet had consisted primarily of dairy products, biscuits, and cereals.
On examination, he appeared cachectic, pale, bradypsychic, oedema with pitting of the lower limbs, and purpuric lesions on his extremities and abdomen. Furthermore, he exhibited arthritis in both knees, for which arthrocentesis was performed and haematic fluid was obtained. In addition, dermatology confirmed perifollicular haemorrhage by dermoscopy and biopsied one of the purpuric lesions (Fig. 1A), the pathology examination of which revealed chronic superficial dermatitis and perifollicular extravasation of blood without vasculitis (Fig. 1C).
Laboratory tests identified normocytic anaemia with associated iron deficiency and indirect evidence of malnutrition. The autoimmunity tests, coagulation study, serology, and radiographic studies were normal and the joint fluid culture was negative (Table 1).
Laboratory test results.
Laboratory results at the time of diagnosis | |
---|---|
Parameter | Value |
Serology: Clostridium tetani, HAV, HBV, HCV, HIV, rubeola, varicella zoster, parvovirus B19, paramyxovirus, measles virus, Quantiferon, Rickettsia coronii, Treponema pallidum | Negative |
Autoimmunity: ANA (ELISA), ANCA-antimyeloperoxidase, ANCA-antiproteinase 3, anti-CCP, anti-cardiolipin antibodies, anti-streptolysin O, anti-β2-glycoprotein antibodies, cryoglobulins | Negative |
C3 and C4 complements | 138 mg/dL (VR 88–201 mg/dL), |
22 mg/dL (VR 10–40 mg/dL) | |
Tumour markers: alpha-fetoprotein, carcinoembryonic antigen, CA 19.9, PSA, squamous cell carcinoma-associated antigen | Negative |
PCR | 1.3 mg/dL (VR 0–0.5 mg/dL) |
ESR | 26 mm/h (VR 0–10 mm/h) |
Haemoglobin, MCV | 8.7 g/dL (VR 13.5–17.5 g/dL), 89.3 fL (VR 80–98 fL) |
Peripheral blood smear | No significant morphological alterations |
Direct Coombs | Negative |
Haemostasis: INR, fibrinogen, prothrombin time, activated partial thromboplastin time, factor II, factor V, factor VII, factor IV, factor X, factor XI, factor XII | Within range |
Factor VIII | 200.8% (VR 50%–150%) |
ADP aggregation | 64 s (VR 68–121 s) |
Epinephrine aggregation | 73 s (VR 84–160 s) |
Folic acid | 4.4 ng/mL (VR 4–20 ng/mL) |
Vitamin B12 | 337 pg/mL (VR 180–414 pg/mL) |
Vitamin K1 | <0,05 µg/L (VR 0.13–1.5 µg/L) |
Vitamin A | 0.04 mg/L (VR 0.3–1 mg/L) |
Vitamin C | <0.10 mg/dL (VR 0.4–2 mg/dL) |
Vitamin D (D2 + D3) | 20 ng/mL (VR 10–30 ng/mL: deficiency) |
Albumin, prealbumin | 3.4 g/dL (VR 3.5–5.2), 11 mg/dL (VR 18–45 mg/dL) |
Faecal occult blood | <30 (VR < 75: negative) |
Laboratory results of the articular fluid of the left knee | |
---|---|
Parameter | Value |
Red blood cells | 550,706 mm3 |
Nucleated cells | 428 mm3 |
Polynuclear | 27% |
Mononuclear | 73% |
Glucose | 80 mg/dL |
Crystals | No crystals observed |
Appearance | Haemorrhagic |
HAV, HBV, HCV: hepatitis A, B, and C virus; HIV: human immunodeficiency virus; ANA: antinuclear antibodies; ELISA: enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; ANCA: antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies, Anti-CCP: anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide; CRP: C reactive protein, ESR = erythrocyte sedimentation rate; MCV: mean corpuscular volume.
In view of the high suspicion of scurvy, intravenous vitamin C was administered, and suppressed levels of vitamins C, A, K1, and zinc were confirmed in the following days (Table 1).
After two weeks of treatment, the patient improved clinically and analytically and was therefore discharged with vitamin complexes and remains asymptomatic at present (Fig. 1B).
DiscussionWhile scurvy is rare in developed countries, cases are still reported among individuals at risk for malnutrition. Vitamin C deficiency alters vascular collagen and leads to bruising, purpura, arthritis, or arthromyalgia that may mimic vasculitis.
A review of the literature revealed 19 cases of scurvy in adults published in the 21st century (Table 2). Of these, 63% were male and had a mean age of 50 years. In almost all cases, the person had some medical or psychiatric history, and in one case, vitamin C deficiency was reported as a complication of enteral nutrition.17 The most frequent clinical manifestations were dermatological, including haematomas or ecchymosis, rash with perifollicular distribution, gingival bleeding, and the characteristic “corkscrew” hairs. Approximately 60% of all cases presented with articular manifestations, the most commonly observed ones being hemarthrosis in the large joints of the lower limbs (mainly knees and ankles) and polyarthralgias. In the cardiorespiratory system, several patients had dyspnoea on minimal exertion secondary to anaemia and/or heart failure.3,11 Other less frequent symptoms were pulmonary hypertension,11 arterial hypotension, and presyncopal episodes that might be attributable to the greater resistance of the blood vessels to the action of adrenaline.18,20 As an atypical manifestation of vitamin C deficiency in connective tissue, Francescone and Levitt reported a case of a 59-year-old male with osteopenia of the sacrum.
Review of scurvy cases in the 21st century.
Author, year | Cases | Country | Sex | Age | History | Symptoms | Biopsy | Vitamin C treatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Martínez et al.6 (2004) | 1 | Spain | F | 90 | Dependent for BADL | Haematomas | No | ID: 1000 mg/24 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Francescone and Levitt7 (2005) | 1 | USA | F | 59 | Low socioeconomic level | Hematomas | Yes | ID: 1000 mg/12 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Polyarthralgia | ||||||||
Osteopenia sacrum | ||||||||
Roé et al.8 (2005) | 1 | Spain | F | 45 | Machado–Joseph disease | Ecchymosis | Yes | ID: 500 mg/12 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | MD: 500 mg/week (per os) | |||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Polyarthralgia | ||||||||
Olmedo et al.9 (2006) | 1 | USA | F | 77 | Food allergies | Hematomas | No | ID: 100 mg/8 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | MD: 100 mg/day (per os) | |||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Léger10 (2008) | 1 | Canada | F | 47 | Alcoholism | Hematomas | Yes | NE |
Léger10 (2008) | Perifollicular rash | |||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Mertens and Gertner11 (2011) | 3 | USA | F | 26 | Low socioeconomic level | Ecchymosis | Yes | ID: 1000 mg/24 h |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Knee hemarthrosis | ||||||||
General syndrome | ||||||||
F | 22 | CP | Ecchymosis | No | ID: 1000 mg/24 h | |||
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Ankle hemarthrosis | ||||||||
F | 74 | Deliriums about food sensitivities | Perifollicular rash | No | ID: 1000 mg/24 h | |||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Arthritic ankles | ||||||||
Dyspnoea (PHTN) | ||||||||
Núñez Fernández et al.12 (2001) | 1 | Spain | F | 67 | Alcoholism | Hematomas | No | NE |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Abou Ziki et al.13 (2015) | 1 | USA | F | MA | NE | Hematomas | No | NE |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Hemarthrosis | ||||||||
Mintsoulis et al.3 (2016) | 1 | Canada | F | 68 | Food allergies | Perifollicular rash | Yes | ID: 100 mg/12 h (iv) |
Hemarthrosis – ankle | MD: 250 mg/day (per os) | |||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Epistaxis | ||||||||
Panniculitis | ||||||||
Loureiro-Amigo et al.14 (2016) | 1 | Spain | F | 28 | Depression | Ecchymosis | No | ID: 1000 mg/24 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Brandy-García et al.15 (2017) | 1 | Spain | F | 42 | Schizophrenia | Perifollicular rash | Yes | NE |
Gingivitis | ||||||||
Knee hemarthrosis | ||||||||
Regehr et al.16 (2021) | 1 | USA | F | 18 | CP | Hematoma | No | ID: 1000 mg/24 h (iv) MD: 250 mg/24 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Lanes Iglesias et al.17 (2020) | 1 | Spain | F | 55 | Dementia | Hematomas | No | Enteral nutrition |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Thomas and Burtson18 (2021) | 1 | USA | F | 69 | Depression | Ecchymosis | No | Multivitamin complex |
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Arterial hypertension | ||||||||
General syndrome | ||||||||
Rodríguez Falabella et al.19 (2023) | 1 | Argentina | F | 48 | Parkinson’s disease | Hematomas | Yes | ID: 500 mg/12 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Bleeding of the gums | ||||||||
Corkscrew hairs | ||||||||
Oligoarthritic ankles | ||||||||
Pope and Elder20 (2023) | 1 | USA | F | 55 | Alcoholism | Hematomas | No | ID: 250 mg/24 h (per os) |
Perifollicular rash | ||||||||
Arthritic knee | ||||||||
Arterial hypertension | ||||||||
Lu et al.21 (2023) | 1 | China | F | 25 | NS | Hematomas | No | ID: 200 mg/8 h (per os) |
Oligoarthritis | ||||||||
Cabaleiro Raña et al. (2024) | 1 | Spain | F | 49 | ED | Perifollicular rash | Yes | ID: 500 mg/24 h (iv) |
Knee hemarthrosis | MD: multivitamin complex |
BADL: basic activities of daily living; ID: initial dose; MD: maintenance dose; PHTN: pulmonary hypertension; iv: intravenous; F: female; MA: median age; NS: not specified; CP: cerebral palsy; ED: eating disorder; M: male; per os: by mouth.
In our case, the history of an eating disorder, hemarthrosis, and desmoscopic findings enabled us to guide the diagnosis. Vitamin C levels are not routinely tested for in laboratory analyses and waiting for the result would delay diagnosis/treatment.
Differential diagnosis is made with purpura-related conditions (vasculitis, infections, idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, Ehlers–Danlos) or bleeding (coagulation disorders). Given that it is a pseudovasculitis, a biopsy is useful to rule out vascular inflammation.3
As regards treatment, the asthenia and skin lesions improved with vitamin C administration, whereas it took the arthritis several weeks to resolve. The anaemia disappeared after one month.5
ConclusionDespite being an extremely rare deficiency disease in Western countries nowadays, scurvy continues to present in isolation in certain patients. The present case is a reminder of the importance of including this pseudovasculitis in the differential diagnosis of any patient with purpuric lesions or hemarthrosis.
Conflict of interestsThe authors have no conflict of interests to declare.